One of the quietest of the January deadline-day transfers was the loan acquisition by Everton of Spurs defender Antony Gardner.
Gardner, just recovered from a broken ankle sustained in Tottenham’s encounter with Getafe, has completed a reserve run out with his new surrogate club, and most of the noises coming out of White Hart Lane are of the "good riddance" variety.
So why did David Moyes sign the much-maligned Gardner, whose prime position is centre-back – one of Everton’s strongest areas with Phil Jagielka, Joleon Lescott and Joseph Yobo all vieing for contention?
The primary reason has to be back-up – with 36-year-old Alan Stubbs leaving for Derby County we looked a tad short at the back if hit by injuries, and Gardner could be a useful 'body' and adds some depth to our usually emaciated squad, especially on a low-risk loan.
From the moment Moyes arrived at Everton, he worked his magic on two fronts. Firstly he realised that funds were finite at Everton, and looked to bring players in on loan, a 'try-before-you-buy' policy, perfectly tailored for Everton and an excellent way to gauge a player and good insurance against any flops.
If a player isn't good enough, then ship him off, if he does make the grade then we can splurge – usually for a pre-agreed price; this policy has worked best with Yobo, Steven Pienaar and even Tim Howard. The consensus amongst Spurs fans is that Gardner is a barrel-scrapingly bad player – described by some at the Lane as "the Heskey of defence". They claim he has no pace, bad control, poor composure, sloppy passing, heading, strength...you name it, he hasn't got it.
Gardner was a focal boo point at Spurs and in that respect he is similar to Kevin Kilbane, a player tossed aside by Sunderland like an underrated Superted. In 1999 Peter Reid paid a whopping £2.5m to bring 'Killer' to Sunderland, making him the third most expensive club signing at the time and setting him up for a huge fall.
Although Kilbane’s start for Sunderland was perfect – he came off the subs' bench on his debut against Southampton and instantly set up Kevin Phillips to score the winning goal, this was to prove a cruelly unique game as the Black Cats nosedived thereafter, something the fans called "The Curse of Kilbane".
Once the boos start, they rarely stop – and scapegoat status was something that Kilbane couldn’t shrug off – relegation followed, and the boos increased. Kilbane had had enough, and in the summer of 2003, on a tour of France, he aimed a two-fingered salute at the Sunderland support, a King Canute sticking his fingers up at the waves of abuse.
Moyes took this apparently useless player to Everton at the beginning of the 2003-04 season for just under £1m, and mild-mannered, gaffe-prone Kilbane became superhero Zinedine Kilbane – a barnstorming player happy to help out in numerous positions on the pitch.
Kilbane has been rejuvenated by Moyes, who sold him on to Wigan for the tidy sum of £2m. Disregard the boos and the opprobrium levelled at Gardner, and his signing makes sense. Like Kilbane, he can play in a number of positions, and after Gardner’s impressive start to the 2003-04 season he got a call-up from Sven-Goran Eriksson to the England side.
Moyes has also been adamant that more height needs to be brought into the squad and at 6ft 5in, Gardner can help us out there, too. Moyes loves to shine up reluctant stars, could it be possible that he’ll tap into untouched potential with Gardner? Let’s hope so…